Carbon copy meaning: what cc and bcc mean in email
Cc means carbon copy and bcc means blind carbon copy. See where the terms come from on the typewriter, how each works in email, and when to use them.
The meaning of carbon copy is literal: it was a duplicate of a letter made by typing through a sheet of carbon paper. Cc in email stands for carbon copy and marks people who get a copy of a message addressed to someone else, and bcc stands for blind carbon copy, a copy the other recipients cannot see.
Carbon copy meaning: the typewriter origin
Carbon paper is thin paper coated on one side with dry ink bound in wax. Put it, ink side down, between two sheets of writing paper, and anything pressed onto the top sheet is transferred to the one beneath.
The idea is older than the typewriter. Pellegrino Turri is credited with inventing carbon paper in Italy in 1801, to supply the ink for an early typing machine, and Ralph Wedgwood took out the first patent for it in England in 1806. It came into wide use only when typewriters became common in offices.
To make copies, a typist stacked letter paper, carbon paper and copy paper in alternate layers and rolled the whole pack into the machine. Every keystroke printed the original through the ribbon and the copies through the carbons. The practical limit was four or five copies. A typing mistake had to be corrected on every sheet.
Carbon copies were ordinary office practice from the 1870s to the 1980s. Photocopiers and then word processors replaced them, though carbon paper is still used in some receipt books and forms.
The cc line on a letter
A business letter that had been copied to other people said so. Below the signature the typist wrote "cc:" followed by the names of everyone who had been sent a copy. That told the addressee who else had read the letter.
There is a second explanation for the double c: that "c:" meant copy and "cc:" meant copies, in the way that "p." and "pp." mean page and pages. Both readings circulate, and the two are hard to separate now.
Blind copies on paper
Sometimes the writer wanted a copy to go to someone without the addressee knowing. The typist left that name off the original and added it only to the copies, either by typing it on them separately afterward or by arranging things so that the name did not print on the top sheet. That was a blind carbon copy.
If you want to see what the original looked like, the online typewriter produces a struck page in your browser, and how to write a typewritten letter covers the layout of a typed letter.
What cc means in email
Email took the terms over directly. A message format published for the ARPA network in November 1977, RFC 733, already had cc and bcc fields, with cc holding the secondary recipients of a message. The current standard, RFC 5322, spells the origin out: it says Cc means carbon copy in the sense of making a copy on a typewriter using carbon paper.
An email has three address fields.
| Field | Who goes there | Who can see these addresses |
|---|---|---|
| To | The people the message is written to, who are expected to act or reply | Everyone who receives the message |
| Cc | People who should know about it but are not being asked to do anything | Everyone who receives the message |
| Bcc | People who should receive it without the others knowing | Only the sender, and in some mail programs the Bcc recipient |
Technically To and Cc are delivered in the same way. The difference is a signal to the reader: To means this is for you, Cc means this is for your information.
Cc has also become a verb, and several spellings of its past tense are in use, including cc'd, cc'ed and CCed.
How bcc works in email
When you send a message, your mail program gives the mail server two things: the message itself, with its visible To and Cc lines, and a separate list of every address to deliver to. Bcc recipients are on the delivery list but not in the visible part.
RFC 5322 leaves the exact handling to each mail program and describes three ways of doing it:
- Remove the Bcc line from the message, then send the same copy to everyone.
- Send the To and Cc recipients a copy without the Bcc line, and send the Bcc recipients a copy that still has it. Some programs show each Bcc recipient only their own address.
- Send the message with an empty Bcc line, which tells recipients that blind copies went to someone without saying who.
So a person you bcc can see the To and Cc recipients, but those recipients cannot see the bcc'd person.
Replies and reply all
- A reply from a To or Cc recipient never reaches the Bcc recipients, because their addresses are not in the message.
- If a Bcc recipient uses reply all, the reply goes to the sender and to everyone in To and Cc. They then learn that the person was copied in secret.
That second case is the usual way a blind copy is exposed.
When to use To, Cc and Bcc
These are conventions, not rules, and workplaces differ. The ones below follow from how the fields work.
Use Cc when
- Someone needs to know that the message was sent but does not need to act on it: a manager, a colleague covering for you, the person who introduced you.
- You want the main recipient to see who else has been told.
Leave people off Cc if they do not need the message. Every extra address is another inbox filled, and another person who may reply to all.
Use Bcc when
- You are writing to a list of people who do not know each other, such as customers or club members. Put your own address in To and the list in Bcc. Nobody's address is shown to strangers, and nobody can reply to the whole list.
- You are moving someone off a thread. Put them in Bcc for one last message and say so in the first line, for example "Moving Dana to bcc". They see that the conversation continued, and later replies no longer reach them.
- You want a copy sent to another address of your own for your records.
Be careful with Bcc when
- You are copying a third person on a conversation in secret. The other reader assumes the message is private, and one reply all reveals the copy. Forwarding the sent message afterward does the same job without that risk.
- The message could ever be read as a formal record. A hidden recipient looks worse later than an open one.
Carbon copy as a figure of speech
Because a carbon copy matched its original mark for mark, the phrase also means a near duplicate of anything: a child who is a carbon copy of a parent, or a second match that is a carbon copy of the first. That sense has outlived the paper.
Sources
Questions people ask
- What does cc mean?
- Cc means carbon copy. In email, the Cc field holds people who should receive a copy of a message that is addressed to someone else. Everyone who receives the message can see who was cc'd.
- What is the meaning of carbon copy?
- A carbon copy is a duplicate made by placing a sheet of carbon paper between two sheets of paper, so that typing or writing on the top sheet marks the one underneath. The phrase is also used for anything that closely duplicates something else.
- What does bcc mean?
- Bcc means blind carbon copy. People in the Bcc field receive the message, but their addresses are not shown to the other recipients.
- Can Bcc recipients see each other?
- Normally no. The email standard leaves the details to each mail program: most remove the Bcc line before sending, and some send each Bcc recipient a copy that shows only that person's own address.
- What happens if a Bcc recipient replies to all?
- The reply goes to the sender and to everyone in the To and Cc fields, which reveals that the person was secretly copied. It does not go to the other Bcc recipients, because their addresses were never in the message.
- Does cc stand for courtesy copy?
- Not originally. The email standard itself says Cc means carbon copy in the typewriter sense. Courtesy copy is a later reading of the same letters, used now that carbon paper is rare.