Keyboard layouts: QWERTY, AZERTY, QWERTZ, Dvorak
The main keyboard layouts compared: QWERTY, AZERTY, QWERTZ, Dvorak and Colemak, plus layouts for other scripts and the evidence on QWERTY vs Dvorak.
Keyboard layouts are the arrangements of letters and symbols on a keyboard. The most common is QWERTY, the main regional variants for the Latin alphabet are AZERTY and QWERTZ, and the best known alternatives are Dvorak and Colemak.
A layout is mostly software. The same physical keyboard can type QWERTY, Dvorak or Russian depending on a setting in the operating system. This article compares the main layouts, covers QWERTY vs Dvorak, and briefly explains how keyboards handle other scripts.
Keyboard layouts compared
Each layout is named after the first six letters of its top row, or after its designer.
| Layout | Top row begins | Mainly used | Letters moved from QWERTY | Origin |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| QWERTY | Q W E R T Y | Most of the world | None | 1870s typewriters |
| AZERTY | A Z E R T Y | France, Belgium | 5 (A, Q, Z, W, M) | France, 1890s |
| QWERTZ | Q W E R T Z | Germany, Austria, Switzerland, central Europe | 2 (Z, Y) | German typewriters |
| Dvorak | ' , . P Y F | Enthusiasts, any country | 24 (all but A and M) | Patented 1936 |
| Colemak | Q W F P G J | Enthusiasts, any country | 17 keys | Released 2006 |
QWERTY
QWERTY is the default for English and many other languages, and it reached computers by way of typewriters and teleprinters. The story of how it took shape, and why the idea that it was built to slow typists down has no support, is told in typewriter keyboard layout.
There is not one QWERTY. National versions add the characters a language needs, so a Spanish keyboard has a key for ñ.
ANSI, ISO and JIS are shapes, not layouts
The physical arrangement of keys is a separate matter from what the keys type. Three physical standards are common:
- ANSI, usual in the United States: a wide Enter key and 104 keys at full size.
- ISO, usual in Europe: a tall Enter key, a shorter left Shift and 105 keys.
- JIS, used in Japan: a shorter space bar and Backspace, which makes room for extra keys.
AZERTY keyboard
The AZERTY keyboard is used in France and Belgium, and in some African countries. It appeared in France in the 1890s as a variation on American typewriter keyboards. Its exact origin is not known.
Compared with QWERTY:
- A and Q swap places.
- Z and W swap places.
- M moves from the bottom row to the right of L.
- On the French version, the number row types accented letters and punctuation, and digits need Shift.
The traditional French layout has long been criticized for making some French characters hard to type, such as capital letters with accents. In April 2019 the French standards body AFNOR published a voluntary standard, NF Z71-300. It describes two layouts: an improved AZERTY that keeps the letters where they are, and a different arrangement called BÉPO. Because the standard is voluntary, the older layout is still common.
QWERTZ keyboard
QWERTZ is the layout of Germany, Austria and Switzerland, and of several central and south-east European countries, including Hungary, Slovakia, Slovenia and Croatia. The Czech Republic uses both QWERTZ and QWERTY.
The defining change is that Z and Y swap. Z is much more common than Y in German, where Y appears mostly in loanwords and names, so Z gets the easier position. German and Austrian keyboards add keys for ä, ö, ü and ß. Swiss keyboards serve both German and French and do not have a ß key.
On most European keyboards, including AZERTY and QWERTZ, the right Alt key is labeled AltGr. Holding it gives a third character on many keys, such as @, the euro sign and brackets.
Dvorak keyboard
The Dvorak keyboard was designed by August Dvorak, an American educational psychologist, with his brother-in-law William Dealey. They finished it in 1932 and patented it in 1936. The American National Standards Institute recognized it as an alternative standard in 1982.
Its principles:
- The home row holds the most used letters of English: A O E U I on the left, D H T N S on the right.
- All the vowels are under the left hand and the most common consonants under the right, so the hands tend to alternate.
- The least used letters go to the bottom row.
A commonly cited estimate is that about 70 percent of English keystrokes fall on the Dvorak home row, against about 32 percent on QWERTY.
Dvorak is built into Windows, macOS, Linux, ChromeOS and Android. Apple added it to the iPhone's on-screen keyboard with iOS 16 in 2022.
QWERTY vs Dvorak: is Dvorak faster?
Less finger movement is well established. Faster typing is not.
The case for Dvorak rests largely on early tests, above all a US Navy experiment in 1944 that reported quick and large gains for retrained typists. According to Strong, whose own study is described next, that experiment was run by Dvorak himself, who held the patent.
In 1956 Earle Strong ran a controlled study for the US General Services Administration. Ten government typists were retrained on Dvorak and took more than 25 days of four-hour sessions to get back to their old QWERTY speed. They then kept training alongside a matched group of ten who trained on QWERTY, and the QWERTY group improved more. Strong concluded that retraining would not pay for itself.
The economists Stan Liebowitz and Stephen Margolis reviewed this history in a 1990 paper, "The Fable of the Keys", and in a later article. They found flaws in the Navy study's design and cited later ergonomic research that put the difference between the layouts at a few percentage points at most. Supporters of Dvorak reply that Strong's study was biased toward the QWERTY group.
Our reading: Dvorak reduces finger travel, and some people find it more comfortable. No sound study shows that it makes a typical typist meaningfully faster, and the claim that it reduces strain injuries has not been tested in a scientific study.
Colemak and other alternative layouts
Colemak was released on 1 January 2006 by Shai Coleman. It aims for the same goal as Dvorak with less disruption:
- Only 17 keys move from their QWERTY positions.
- Z, X, C and V stay put, so the shortcuts for undo, cut, copy and paste are unchanged.
- The home row is A R S T D H N E I O.
- Caps Lock becomes a second Backspace.
Colemak is built into macOS, Linux, Android and ChromeOS, and into Windows from Windows 11 version 24H2. Older Windows versions need an installer.
Colemak-DH is a community variant that moves D and H off the center column to avoid a sideways stretch. We found no independent speed trials for Colemak or its variants.
Keyboard layouts for other scripts
Languages that do not use the Latin alphabet have their own layouts, usually printed on the keys next to the Latin letters.
| Script | Common layout | How it works |
|---|---|---|
| Cyrillic (Russian) | JCUKEN (ЙЦУКЕН) | The main Russian layout, named after its top row. Ukrainian, Belarusian and Kazakh layouts are based on it. |
| Devanagari and other Indian scripts | InScript | Standardized by the Government of India in 1986. One arrangement serves many Indian scripts because they share a phonetic order. |
| Korean (Hangul) | Dubeolsik | Each key types one letter (jamo), and the computer groups them into syllable blocks as you type. |
| Japanese | JIS | Keys carry kana as well as Latin letters. Most people type romanized syllables, and software converts them to kana and kanji. |
| Chinese | QWERTY with an input method | Mainland keyboards are usually plain QWERTY. The typist enters pinyin and picks the characters. Keyboards in Taiwan often carry Zhuyin symbols. |
| Hebrew and Arabic | National layouts | Text runs right to left. Keyboards in Israel carry both Hebrew and Latin letters. |
Should you switch layout?
Use the layout your language and country expect unless you have a specific reason not to. Consider what switching costs:
- Relearning. Expect weeks of slow typing. In the 1956 study above, trained typists needed more than 100 hours of practice to get back to their old speed.
- Other people's computers. Shared, school and work machines will usually be on the local default.
- Shortcuts. Dvorak moves the cut, copy and paste keys. Colemak does not.
Better technique on the layout you have is the cheaper experiment. Touch typing and the habits in how to type faster apply to every layout.
If you do switch, change the setting in your operating system, then use the keyboard test to see what each physical key registers, and track your progress with a typing test. The online typewriter types whatever your system layout sends, so it works with any of them.
Sources
- Keyboard layout, Wikipedia, for physical standards and non-Latin layouts
- AZERTY, Wikipedia and AFNOR on the French keyboard standard
- QWERTZ, Wikipedia
- Dvorak keyboard layout, Wikipedia
- Liebowitz and Margolis, "Typing Errors", Reason, 1996
- Colemak FAQ and Colemak, Wikipedia
- InScript keyboard, Wikipedia and JCUKEN, Wikipedia
Questions people ask
- What are the main keyboard layouts?
- For the Latin alphabet they are QWERTY, used in most of the world, AZERTY in France and Belgium, and QWERTZ in Germany, Austria, Switzerland and much of central Europe. Dvorak and Colemak are alternative layouts designed to reduce finger movement in English.
- Is the Dvorak keyboard faster than QWERTY?
- It has not been shown convincingly. Tests run by its inventor in the 1940s reported large gains, but a controlled US government study in 1956 found no advantage, and later reviews found differences of a few percent at most. Both sides of the evidence have been criticized.
- What is the difference between QWERTY and AZERTY?
- AZERTY swaps A with Q and Z with W, and moves M to the right of L. On the French version the digits need Shift, because the number row gives accented letters and punctuation first.
- What is the difference between QWERTY and QWERTZ?
- QWERTZ swaps Z and Y, since Z is far more common than Y in German. German and Austrian keyboards also have keys for ä, ö, ü and ß.
- What is Colemak?
- Colemak is an alternative layout for English released on 1 January 2006 by Shai Coleman. It moves 17 keys from their QWERTY positions and keeps the Z, X, C and V shortcuts where they are, which makes it easier to learn for a QWERTY typist than Dvorak.
- Can I change my keyboard layout without buying a new keyboard?
- Yes. The layout is a software setting. Windows, macOS, Linux, Android and iOS all let you choose a different layout, and the letters printed on the keys simply stop matching what the keys type.